Hungary to face EU court over foreign influence law

Copyright: European Union

The European Union is taking Hungary’s right-wing government to court challenging “sovereignty protection” laws enacted last December that empower Hungarian authorities to investigate and prosecute individuals and organisations accused of undermining the country’s sovereignty. The controversial law resulted in a government body authorised to collect data on groups or individuals that might benefit from foreign funding, thereby influencing public debate.

Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s government insists that the new legislation was introduced to prevent Hungarian political parties from receiving funding from abroad for election campaigns. Opponents, however, claim the measures are no different than Russia’s “foreign agent” law, which considers anyone receiving financial support from abroad as agents of another country. In Hungary, those opposed to the new law maintain that the legislative language is deliberately broad, so that the authorities there can target government critics arbitrarily, especially NGOs and  members of the media. Those found to be in violation of the new measures are liable to prison sentences of up to three years.

In June, the new office charged with defending against foreign influence began an investigation into the Hungarian branch of Transparency International, the anti-corruption NGO. Media have been targeted as well. According to the European Commission, the new office’s powers are so broad and potentially intrusive that it can “affect a wide range of persons and entities, including civil society organizations, media outlets and journalists in a disproportionate manner.”
The European Commission (EC) declared it was referring  the issue to the EU Court of Justice because of Hungary’s failure to address concerns about the implicit threats to EU membership fundamental rights principles, notably the right to privacy and to freedom of expression and association.
In June, the new office charged with defending against foreign influence began an investigation into the Hungarian branch of Transparency International, the anti-corruption NGO. Media have been targeted as well. According to the EC, the new office’s powers are so broad and potentially intrusive that it can “affect a wide range of persons and entities, including civil society organizations, media outlets and journalists in a disproportionate manner.”

The referral to the court action is the latest move in the contentious relationship between Brussels and Budapest. Most recently, Hungary, as current holders of the EU’s rotating presidency, caused dismay among partner members when, at the onset of its presidential term. Prime Minister Orbán unilaterally took it upon himself to visit Moscow to discuss prospects for a peaceful settlement in Ukraine with President Vladimir Putin.

Explore more